More on Amateurism

In answer to Gillian Martin's question, I have one amateur performance that I remember vividly. This was a soprano--unfortunately I don't remember her name--who entered the Metropolitan Opera auditions some years back, and sang the Letter Aria from Douglas Moore's "Ballad of Baby Doe."

I suppose it was the "aria in English" that many auditions require, and it's not a piece that is necessarily going to knock an audience's socks off. But in her performance, what directness and simplicity she gave it:

Dearest Mama, I am writing

For I'm lonely and distressed. . . .

I'm not sure if it happened because she was an amateur, or because she was a talented singer. I suspect the latter; to paraphrase Andre Gide, in the arts, sincerity is the hardest thing to achieve.