From the Mailbag: Trumpeting Around
Mike from California writes:
Having heard some more fanfares on your British show ... wondering ... why organ "trumpets" almost always are a loud reed. Sort of like God's own Oboe with an edge. I guess real trumpets are reeds, too, with the players lips standing in for something mechanical, but that produces a very different sound. IIRC, the Wanamaker has a fairly real sound trumpet, but most other trumpet stops don't. They're loud, but sound kind of "pinched" - except for those classic old Spanish and southern French concoctions, which sound good regardless.
What might be kind of interesting would be to add a digital trumpet stop, perhaps with samples from somebody doing jazz trumpet - Marsalis or Armstrong records?
Hmmm...what might an organ Trumpet be if not a loud reed?
Organ reed pipes sound the way they do because that's the way they sound. Keep in mind that these sorts of pipes were first developed back @1450, when actual trumpets probably sounded similarly thin. I imagine that the 'classic' organ trumpet pipe continues in this line as a matter of tradition, though later 19th and early 20th century builders (particularly the English) did evolve rounder sounding 'tuba' stops.
I would not much like to hear a digital trumpet 'stop' attempt to sound like Marsalis or Armstrong.
However, any of the recordings by Dan Bellomy might come close. He uses the Wurlitzer Posthorn as though it were a jazz man's axe.
Before you go...
Thank you for choosing YourClassical as your go-to for your classical music. In addition to the variety of music streams we have, we’re proud to offer features like the one you’re reading right now. Help us continue to give you what you love by making a gift today, in support of YourClassical.